Website
https://lantern-in-the-dark.my.canva.site/
Paige Butcher
PMHNP (Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner), APRN (Advanced Practice Registered Nurse), RN (Registered Nurse)
About
I am a Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner serving adults throughout Ohio through virtual and in-person appointments. My passion is helping people find hope and healing by caring for the whole person—mind, body, and spirit.
My practice, Lantern in the Dark, reflects the biblical truth that God is our light, even in our darkest seasons. I integrate Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) with Biblical truth, helping clients learn to “take every thought captive” (2 Corinthians 10:5). Sessions include prayer, Scripture, and the application of Biblical principles integrated with evidence-based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT).
My approach is therapy-first. While I can prescribe non-controlled medications when clinically appropriate, I believe lasting change comes through renewing the mind with God’s truth alongside evidence-based therapy.
As a nondenominational Christian, I welcome clients from all Christian denominations. I believe the Holy Spirit leads every session and that God is the ultimate source of healing. My practice focuses on obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), generalized anxiety disorder (GAD), major depressive disorder (MDD), post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and related conditions that can be safely and effectively treated in an outpatient setting.
The verse that has most shaped my life and practice is 2 Corinthians 5:7: “For we walk by faith, not by sight.” I also find great encouragement in Micah 7:8: “…When I sit in darkness, the Lord will be a light to me.” These verses remind me that even when we cannot see the path ahead, God is faithful and present.
My desire is to provide a compassionate, grace-filled space where clients can strengthen both their mental health and their relationship with Christ while trusting Him to guide the journey toward healing.
Provider details
Non-profit
No
For Profit
No
Did a clinician start the program?
No
Does a clinician have significant leadership responsibilities?
No
Do you have a doctrinal statement?
No
Number of Beds
0
Accreditation
- Other State or National Accreditations
Christian Programming
No
Full Christian Program
No
Christian Track in a Secular Program
No
No overt Christian track but have Christian staff if a patient desires
No
Mental Health Only
Yes
Addiction
No
Severe Restrictive Eating Disorder with low BMI
No
Development Disabilities
No
Level of Functioning
High
Dual – Patient has both a MH and Addiction diagnosis
No
Cognitive deficits
No
Dementia
No
Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI)
No
Impairment
High
Sex Offenders
No
Incarcerated or adjudicated
No
Medical Model with nurses and clinicians
No
Christian Residential Discipleship Program (longer term stay with Bible Study, life skills, work part time)
Without Licensed BH specialists
Inpatient Psychiatry (IP)
No
Inpatient Dual Diagnosis
No
Residential Treatment Center (RTC) - Live on campus with 24/7 nursing and medical providing daily programming with clinicians
No
Partial Hospital Program (PHP)
No
Intensive Outpatient (IOP)
No
Outpatient (OP)
Mental Health therapy, Psychiatric Medication, Combined Care
Program Average Length of Stay (ALOS)
N/A
Programs minimum LOS
N/A
If RTC or PHP
N/A
Psychiatry
Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner
Therapists
Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioner
Primary Care Clinician providing non-psychiatric Initial History and Physical and then any medical services on site
No
Nursing 24/7
No
Pastors on site regularly for patient care
No
Mcare
No
Mcaid
No
Private Pay
No
Most Common Disorders Treated
- Anxiety Disorders
- Depressive Disorders
- Trauma related disorders
Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation
No
Equine Assisted Therapy
No
Wilderness Program
No
EMDR
No
Art Therapy
No
Nutraceuticals
No
Novel Therapies Provided Others
Supportive Therapy with Christian Faith Integration
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy informed
Exposure and Response Prevention informed
Psychiatric Medication Management
Homosexuality - Sexual relations or romantic relationship with same biological sex partner is wrong.
No
Transgender or Gender Confusion - A person’s gender/sex is assigned at birth, and encoded in their DNA as either XX or XY. It is not based on a person’s thoughts, feelings, beliefs or views. And Gender Affirming Therapy is malpractice and harmful to the patient.
No
Sexual activity – should only be between 2 married and consenting adults, one a male and the other a female.
No
Abortion – the killing of an innocent human life is wrong.
No
Euthanasia – administering any chemical to prematurely bring on the death of a person is wrong, regardless of who administers the chemical.
Yes
Physician Assisted Suicide – providing meds, advice, encouragement, or assistance to commit suicide, or have someone kill them is wrong.
Yes
Languages Other Than English
No
Notes/Other Important Elements
Welcome to Lantern in the Dark LLC. As a Board-Certified Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner running a solo private practice, I offer a unique blend of supportive talk therapy and intentional Christian faith integration. I specialize in looking at the whole person—mind, body, and spirit.
While I focus heavily on evidence-based counseling, I have the medical background to manage psychiatric medications if absolutely necessary. My clinical goal is to use the lowest effective doses for the shortest time possible.
Clinical Focus & Modalities:
-
Specialties: Anxiety, Depression, Trauma, and OCD.
-
Therapy Approaches: Supportive Psychotherapy and CBT, including Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP).
-
Prescribing Limits: Controlled substances (such as Adderall, Ritalin, Xanax, or Klonopin) are not prescribed or managed here.
Practice Logistics:
-
Structure: Solo PMHNP practice (not a multi-provider center or clinic).
-
Ages Served: Adults ages 18 and up.
-
Format: Secure telehealth across Ohio, or in-person at 6280 S Main St, Ashtabula, OH 44004.
-
In-Network Insurance: Aetna, Cigna, Anthem BCBS, Providence, and Carelon (Ohio only).
-
Self-Pay / Out-of-Network: Rates range from $90 to $150. Superbills can be provided for out-of-network reimbursement (excludes Medicare/Medicaid).
To Schedule: Please call 440-207-0831 or email paigebutcher@lanterninthedark.org.
Do you agree that counseling is not fully Christian if a counselor’s faith shapes their posture but not their methods?
Yes
Do you agree that the deepest personal help a person needs cannot be fully received apart from faith in Christ, even through counseling?
Yes
Do you agree that Scripture speaks authoritatively to the deepest roots of human problems?
Yes
Do you agree that it is not appropriate to support or affirm a client’s chosen course of action when it conflicts with Scripture, even in the name of autonomy?
Yes
Do you agree that people do not possess all the internal resources needed for truth and healing apart from God, regardless of insight, support, or time?
Yes
Agree with the AACC Doctrinal Statement
Yes
Do you agree with the AACC Ethical Position
Yes
Other Accreditation
N/A (solo private practice)
Clinician's Sex/Gender
Female
Handicap Accessible
Yes
Cities
- Ashtabula
- Conneaut
- Kingsville
- Madison
- Jefferson
Counties
- Ashtabula
- Trumbull
- Lake and Peninsula
- Geauga
ZIPs
- 44003
- 44004
- 44010
- 44030
- 44041
Teleheath
Yes
Psychiatric Evaluations (Psychiatrists or Nurse Practitioners)
- 60 min
- 75-90 min
Individual Sessions
- 50-60 min
Medication Management
- 20-30 min
- 45-60 min
Other Sessions
- Telehealth
Psychological Testing
No
Ages
- Adult (18-70)
Talk Therapies
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT),
- Exposure Response Prevention (ERP)
- Mindfulness
Somatic Therapies
- Medication Management
Strengths
- Anxiety
- Depression
- Obsessive compulsive disorder
- Trauma and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Biblical Integration – Verbally integrating Biblical principles, passages, doctrines, stories, and information into your treatment session
Yes
Do you utilize homework’s assignments for patients to do in between sessions?
Yes
What type of treatment approach do you utilize most frequently?
- Patient led approach
- Problem focused approach
How direct is your approach with patients?
- I share my insights, opinions, views and expertise with the patient
Cost Per Session
Evaluations
60 min $150
Individual Sessions
60 min $90 (therapy, no medication)
Medication Management
30 min $90 (medication only, no therapy)
60 min $100 (combined medication and therapy)
Payment Methods Accepted
- Cash
- Credit Card
Accepted Insurance Plans
- Aetna
- Cigna
- Anthem
- Other
Do you accept payment plans
No
Do you provide or work with an organization that provides loans for treatment
No
Educational History
- School:Youngstown State University
- Degree:Undergrad
- School:Kent State University
- Degree:Masters Degree
Years In Practice
4
License Numbers
- Name:State License
- Number:APRN.CNP.0031474
- State:
- OH
- Name:State License
- Number:RN.450852
- State:
- OH
- Name:DEA
- Number:MB7297408
- State:
- OH
- Name:Board Certifications
- Number:PMHNP-BC 202202569
- State:
- OH
Professional Associations
- AACC
- Other
Which state(s) do you offer Telehealth
- OH
Professional Associations Other
American Psychiatric Nurses Association (APNA)
